Local Specialty Bakeries & Cafes | Elizabeth City, NC Arrivalist
Photo:
Search Elizabeth City Search Elizabeth City HarborCam HarborCam Subscribe Today Email Sign-Up Home Home

Local Specialty Bakeries & Cafes

We enjoy delicious options for quick meals or for sweet cravings in Elizabeth City! Get a coffee or a cookie or a sandwich at these inspired, locally-owned spots. Some have served the Elizabeth City area for years and are loved by generations of locals--others are brand new and impressing locals with their new ideas!


Berri-Licious Frozen Yogurt Bar
1725 City Center Blvd
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

Delectable frozen yogurt with toppings to create a masterpiece! Relax in our fun and vibrant space or check out our drive through for a quick pick-me-up -- either way, it’s going to be delicious.

Colonial Café
418 East Colonial Avenue
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Based on 31 Reviews


Serving classic American breakfast and lunch 7 days a week in a casual diner atmosphere in historic Elizabeth City, North Carolina. We specialize in filling your belly with delicious home-cooked food. Some of our local favorites are our homemade sausage gravy on freshly baked biscuits and our shrimp & grits.
Electric Garden
608 E.Fearing Street
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

Electric Garden takes pride in providing a high quality plant beverage that is aimed to nourish down to the cellular level. Our mission is to spread our love for organic fruits and vegetables to our local community and then unto the world. The people of Elizabeth City have spoken...the direction is a healthy one.
Homestyle Bakery & Café
407 South Griffin Street, Suite E
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

Visit our bakery & café at The Shoppes for lunch or a sweet snack!  We also offer event planning services and specialty cake orders.
In & Out Cafe
1621B North Road Street
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

Elizabeth City's brand new breakfast and lunch spot is open. Stop by In & Out Cafe for New York-style bagels and tall sandwiches - or just a coffee! A favorite is an Asiago cheese bagel or a sandwich with double meat! Try this new, cute little cafe between 6:00 am and 2:00 pm.
Main Street Tea House
104 W Main Street
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

This is the Southern High-Tea experience you've been waiting for! Immerse yourself in the world of international tea, delicate finger sandhwhiches, and freshly baked desserts of many kinds! Main Street Tea House is full of history, stories, culture, and so much more. Treat yourself to an afternoon of pure delight with Elizabeth City's very own tea house, Main Street Tea House.

Muddy Waters Coffeehouse
100 West Main Street
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Based on 105 Reviews


Great coffee is hard to find, but you will find it here! House-roasted beans, hand-crafted drinks by experienced baristas and homemade treats. Doing it Downtown for 24 Years! Sip like a local and enjoy Muddy's Family-friendly, and pet friendly atmosphere! 
Mustang Cafe at Alligood Commons
701 North Poindexter Street
Elizabeth City, NC 27909


Nu-Quality Ice Cream
801 North Hughes Boulevard
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Based on 15 Reviews


Established in 1960, Nu-Quality Ice Cream is one of the best local ice cream shops in town.

Southern Maid Donuts of Elizabeth City
101 Capital Trace
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Based on 8 Reviews


Made-fresh daily donuts and coffee and much, much more. You have tried the rest now come taste the best.
The Kraken Coffee House
615 E Main Street
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

Are you ready to be served nautical-themed coffee and espresso? This new trendy coffee house is ready to show off its delicious baked goods and refreshing drinks. From coffee to matcha, this coffee house has something enjoyable for everyone! 

The Pineapple Café
1775 Weeksville Road
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Based on 30 Reviews


The Pineapple Café features delicious wraps and sandwiches! Great place for a quick soup and salad.

The Sandwich Market
410 Selden Street
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

TripAdvisor Traveler Rating

Based on 33 Reviews


The Sandwich Market is a deli specializing in premium sandwiches at a great price with superb service.
The SweetEasy
507 E Main Street, Suite C
Elizabeth City, NC 27909

The SweetEasy quickly became a downtown staple as locals love the drinks and desserts at this downtown spot! Stop in to sample our creative daily specials - chocolate / potato chip cookies, fresh fruit push-pops, fun flavored macarons, seasonal scones, and anything else that strikes us and is delicious. Our coffees, bubble teas, and lemonades should not be missed.

Email Us